The Sentence Review Division (the "Division") is established and governed pursuant to Section 46-18-901, et. seq., MCA, wherein the Chief Justice of the Montana Supreme Court appoints three district court judges to act as a review division of the Montana Supreme Court.  Each judge serves a three-year term, with one judge designated as the presiding officer or chairperson.  Additionally, the Chief Justice appoints an alternate judge to serve a three-year term.  The alternate judge substitutes in the hearing(s) when the sentencing judge is a member of the Division.

A Defendant who has received a sentence of incarceration for a term of one year or more in the Montana State Prison or to the custody of the Montana Department of Corrections, has a right to apply to the Sentence Review Division for a review of his/her district court sentence.  The Division has adopted Rules that clarify and expedite its application and review process.  The sentence imposed by the district court is presumed correct.  However, upon its review, the Division may order a different sentence to be imposed if it is clearly inadequate or clearly excessive (increase, decrease or modify) or may affirm the sentence imposed by the district court.  The Defendant has a right to appear and be represented by counsel at his/her sentence review hearing or may waive that right. 

A Decision of the Division in each case is final.  The Decisions are published annually in the Montana State Reporter, are filed with the Clerk of District Court where the case originated, and will be posted on this site for two years.

Nov 2024 Decisions
Chair:
Hon. Luke Berger
5th Judicial District
2 S. Pacific St. 
Dillon, MT  59725
Term ending: 12/31/2024
Members:
Hon. Jessica Fehr
13th Judicial District
P.O. Box 35029
Billings, MT  59107
Term ending: 12/31/2025
Hon. Matthew Cuffe
19th Judicial District
512 California Ave.
Libby, MT  59923
Term ending: 12/31/2026
Alternate Members:
Hon. John Warner Alternate Member
1064 Angler Bend Way
Missoula, MT  59802
Term ending: 12/31/2024 
Staff:
Shelly Smith
Office Administrator
301 S. Park, Ste. 328
P.O. Box 203005
Helena, MT 59620-3005
(406) 841-2976
shellysmith@mt.gov
Rosemary Madero
Administrative Assistant
301 S. Park, Ste. 328
P.O. Box 203005
Helena, MT 59620-3005
(406) 841-2977
rosemary.madero@mt.gov

MONTANA STATE PRISON

NOVEMBER 2024                            
Nov 2024 Decisions
Anderson, Peyton M. Powell Co. DC-22-074 - Affirmed
Amsdill, Joshua M. Missoula Co. DC-21-101 - Cont. to February 2025
Aradia, Panda E.  Yellowstone Co. DC-22-1374 - Dismissed Without Prejudice
Bigknife, Marshall  Lake Co. DC-22-276 - Decreased
Black, Brandon L. Fergus Co. DC-14-060 - Cont. to February 2025
Brooks, Macio N.    Missoula Co. DC-15-126 - Dismissed Without Prejudice
Campa, Gilbert  Yellowstone Co. DC-07-531 - Affirmed
Campa, Gilbert Yellowstone Co. DC-07-917 - Affirmed
Curry, Scott E. Jefferson Co. DC-23-018 - Cont. to February 2025
Dean, James W. Richland Co. DC-14-125 - Affirmed
Duferrena, David A. Missoula Co. DC-19-561 - Cont. to February 2025
Daychild, Elliott Q. Lewis & Clark Co. DC-23-285 - Cont. to February 2025
Gomez, Emmanuel F. Missoula Co. DC-16-017 - Affirmed
Goodrie, George L. Yellowstone Co. DC-21-1113 - Cont. to February 2025
Gallo, Lukas M. Missoula Co. DC-22-020 - Dismissed With Prejudice
Garaas, Jeremy L. Richland Co. DC-23-096 - Dismissed With Prejudice
Green, Tyler O. Missoula Co. DC-23-504 - Dismissed With Prejudice
Herman, Cloise C. Fergus Co. DC-23-032 - Cont. to February 2025
Jackson, David S. Gallatin Co. DC-20-534 - Cont. to February 2025
Left Hand, Corbin D. Big Horn Co. DC-23-041 - Affirmed
Leider, Calvin M. Big Horn Co. DC-23-071 - Cont. to February 2025
Lewis, Brandon S. Fergus Co. DC-23-027 - Dismissed Without Prejudice
Lewis, Brandon S. Fergus Co. DC-23-074 - Dismissed Without Prejudice
McNamara, Joseph J. Ravalli Co. DC-19-120 - Affirmed
Mulligan, Dana V. Dawson Co. DC-23-011 - Affirmed
New, Andrew J. Yellowstone Co. DC-24-164 - Affirmed
Old Elk, Jr., Lyle N. Big Horn Co. DC-18-016 - Affirmed
Opie, Jeremy P. Yellowstone Co. DC-23-768 - Cont. to February 2025
Osen, Dane B. Valley Co. DC-19-016 - Dismissed Without Prejudice
Pando, Justin G. Cascade Co. DC-22-701 - Dismissed With Prejudice
Pinner, Charles H. Roosevelot Co. DC-15-044 - Affirmed
Smith, Chevy D. Richland Co. DC-23-091 - Cont. to February 2025
Spotted Blanket, Dustin L. Lake Co. DC-23-378 - Dismissed With Prejudice
St. John, Sunny J. Silver Bow Co. DC-23-266 - Affirmed
Sterling-Shanahan, Ronan Ravalli Co. DC-22-225 - Affirmed
Turner, Curtis R. Powder River Co. DC-23-480 - Affirmed
Vanderpan, Cornelius J. Lewis & Clark Co. DC-23-444 - Cont. to February 2025
Wheeler, Bryan M. Missoula Co. DC-22-074 - Cont. to February 2025

AUGUST 2024
MAY 2024
FEBRUARY 2024
NOVEMBER 2023
AUGUST 2023
MAY 2023
FEBRUARY 2023
NOVEMBER 2022

MONTANA WOMEN'S PRISON

APRIL 2024
SEPTEMBER 2023
APRIL 2023

MEN'S HEARINGS

  • February 6 - 7, 2025
  • May 1 - 2, 2025
  • August 7 - 8, 2025
  • November 6 - 7, 2025

WOMEN'S HEARINGS

  • April 4, 2025
  • September 26, 2025